So sad too bad, Ramielle left last week. Like I said though, someone had too. Tomorrow is Idol Gives Back, so we have to wait til Thursday for the results, but whatever. I’m not all into thier Charity attempt. Call me jaded or whatever, but… meh.
Micheal Johns: It was a decent my performance. Can’t say it was my fav from him, but… Randy kinda agrees, and says it was just “a’right.” Paula says her Chihuahuas would join him on stage after the high note. *side note, Paula’s “twins” look as if they are desperately trying to escape the prison that is that dress. Ouch!* Simon says he doesn’t buy the Micheal Johns, Rock Star. Blues/R&B is a better fit for him.
Syesha: she is about to commit a big Idol no-no. Singing a song by a former Idol, I believe by Fantasia. This could be great, or could end in a bloody mess. So far so good. Oh great. This is the gospel choir one. You know, I didn’t like this one much when Fantasia did it. and that last note… It was awesome, but since I already have a headache, OUCH! Randy says she didn’t measure up to Fantasia. Paula is trying to smooth over the massive dump Randy took on her pride. Simon says that it was technically good, but it lacked emotion.
Jason Castro: Over the rainbow He’s playing a ukulele on National TV. I mean… He’s a good singer, but it looks like he couldn’t afford a real guitar. He just looks ridiculous up there with itty bitty wanna be guitar. Sounded good, but I can’t get past how ridiculous it looked. Randy says, Castro’s back, Paula said it took guts, Simon loved it. Ugh. I can’t get over the Ukulele.
Kristy Lee Cook: Anyway by Martina. This is her element. Country. The song was chopped up by time constraints… and the pitch moments that Randy points out weren’t really pitch moments as much as emotion in the song. Paula proclaims it’s excellent. Simon says that she has the chance to show who she is as an artist, and that she did, and she looks like a star, and appealed to her audience.
David Cook: he is a rocker, fo’ real. I don’t know that song… but you couldn’t miss the message on his hand, Idol “gives back.” Randy says it fell short tonight. I agree. Paula tries to bring the sunshine, and Simon says it felt “pompous.” Paula looks like she’s ready to deck Simon.
Carly: Show must Go On by Queen. Could be good… let’s see. It was ok. Randy says it was just OK. Paula actually agrees, and says she didn’t feel engaged with the song. Simon says she over-sang it and it came over as an angry performance.
David Archuleta: Angels He’s playing a piano… Awesome. I’m not feeling this one. I just don’t like the slower type of song on this show. doesn’t help that I can’t understand a word he’s singing, and I’ve never heard this song b4. Randy says the runs at the end were crazy crazy crazy hot. Paula says fantastic. Simon says best song choice of the night, but not the best vocal.
Simon took security guards into the crowd with him this week, cuz all those screaming girls last week freaked him out.
Brooke White: I’m not feeling it… somehow it sounds wrong, like she’s too nervous or something. It just doesn’t sound good at all. Randy tries to sugar coat it, saying that it wasn’t his fav, but it was OK. Paula says it’s one of her fav songs, and she’s awesome. Simon says it was like a pleasant walk in the park. Um. I guess.
Bottom three – Brooke, Syesha, and Jason Castro – just cuz I didn’t like the ukulele.
So who’s going? I say Brooke. what say you?
I hope not Brooke, I really like her…but it was not a good night for her in my opinion.